Collecting Vintage Pocket Watches - A Guide

Posted on

With their intricate engravings and delicate chains, vintage pocket watches beckoned us to a time when style and craftsmanship were a mark of pride for the watchmaker. Today, the ornate cases and rhythm of an antique pocket watch whisper tales of a bygone era. For those who have been bitten by the vintage bug, collecting pocket watches is a passion.

Like fine art or wine, collecting vintage pocket watches requires an eye for detail, a love for history, and some insider knowledge. If you're looking to start or refine your collection, here are some crucial tips and tricks to help you navigate the world of antique timekeeping.

Understand the Anatomy of a Vintage Pocket Watch

Before starting a vintage pocket watch collection, it's crucial to learn the basic anatomy of these horological gems.

The Dial 

Central to a pocket watch's identity is its dial. Typically crafted from porcelain or metal, dials are the backdrop for numerals and hands indicating time. The artistry and detail found on some vintage dials, from hand-painted scenes to ornate numeral fonts, often reflect the era in which they were made and play a crucial role in identifying and dating a watch.


The watch's case, which encases the dial, is essential for safeguarding the delicate internals from external elements. Materials for cases have varied dramatically over the centuries. From luxurious gold and sterling silver to more common brass, the choice of material often indicated the watch's market positioning. The craftsmanship of the case, especially any engraving or embellishments, can offer insights into its origin and value.


The movement, the heart of the watch, is the intricate mechanism responsible for timekeeping. Movements can be manual, where the wearer winds the watch, or automatic, harnessing energy from the wearer's movements. The complexity, finishing, and accuracy of a watch's movement showcase the watchmaker's prowess, offering collectors a glimpse into the technological advancements of bygone eras.

By understanding these fundamental components—the dial, case, and movement—a budding collector lays a solid foundation for appreciating, evaluating, and cherishing vintage pocket watches.

Research Vintage Pocket Watches

Like any worthy endeavour, it is important to arm yourself with knowledge before starting a collection. Books, online forums, and collector groups are gold mines for vintage watch collectors. Read up on the history of pocket watches, learn about the major manufacturers, and educate yourself on the evolution of pocket watch styles. Brands like Waltham, Elgin, and Hamilton have left indelible marks on the pocket watch landscape, so knowing about them will give you a great head start.

Authenticating Vintage Pocket Watches

One of the most critical aspects of collecting vintage pocket watches is ensuring the item's authenticity. Because of their popularity, vintage pieces often attract counterfeiters and those seeking to pass off replicas as genuine articles. There are several key things to consider to safeguard oneself against such deceptions.

Serial Numbers

Genuine vintage pocket watches will frequently bear serial numbers engraved by their manufacturers. These numbers are more than just arbitrary digits; they're a roadmap to the watch's lineage. By referencing these numbers against manufacturer records or trusted databases, you can pinpoint the production date, model and sometimes even gain insights into where it was initially sold. For a collector, this verifies authenticity and provides a tangible connection to the watch's past.

Vintage Pocket Watch Markings

Next, check for the manufacturer's marks. Typically, authentic watches have stamps, engravings, or markings denoting their maker. These marks can be found on various watch parts, including the case, movement, or even on the dial. Recognizing these emblems and distinguishing genuine marks from those on counterfeits is a vital skill honed over time and with experience.

Era-Appropriate Parts and Materials

Lastly, while knowing what to look for is essential, it's equally important to recognize what shouldn't be there. Inconsistencies in a watch can raise red flags. For instance, mismatched parts—like a dial that doesn't belong to the claimed era or model—can indicate tampering. Similarly, modern screws or components that seem out of place for a vintage piece can be telltale signs of a reproduction or a timepiece that's been heavily modified.

Assessing the Condition and Value of a Vintage Pocket Watch

Evaluate the Condition

A watch's condition can significantly influence its value. When assessing the condition of the timepiece, look at the following areas.

  • Working Movement: Does the watch keep time accurately? Is the movement smooth?
  • Dial Condition: Cracks, chips, or discolorations can reduce value.
  • Case Integrity: Dents, scratches, or signs of excessive polishing can detract from its condition and value.

Rarity and Provenance Matter

The rarer the watch, the higher its potential value. Limited-edition models or those with unique features are especially coveted. If a pocket watch has a documented history or once belonged to a person of note, its value can increase substantially.

Beware of the Price Pitfall

While it's easy to be swayed by high prices, assuming they denote quality, this isn't always the case. Instead of going for the priciest option, aim for a piece that resonates with your taste and has authenticity, quality, and rarity.

Preserving a Vintage Pocket Watch

To ensure your vintage pocket watch collection remains in the best possible condition for the longest time, it's vital to follow appropriate care and storage guidelines. Here are a few tips.

  • Store properly. Invest in a specially designed pocket watch case or storage box that is lined with soft material. This prevents the watch from getting scratched or damaged.
  • Watch its Environment. Moisture is a nemesis for pocket watches. Always store your watch in a dry place. Using silica gel packets in the storage box can help absorb any excess moisture. Similarly, prolonged exposure to sunlight can fade the watch's dial and case. It can also harm the internal mechanics. Finally, extreme hot and cold temperatures can harm the watch's internal mechanisms. Store it in a location with a consistent, moderate temperature.
  • Keep it Upright. If possible, store the watch in an upright position. This position reduces the stress on the watch's mechanics.
  • Regularly Wind the Watch. Even if you don’t use the watch, winding it at least once a week ensures that the gears and springs remain lubricated and functional. However, always be gentle when winding your watch. Overwinding can strain or break the internal components.
  • Cleaning and Maintenance. Use a soft, lint-free cloth to gently wipe away dust or fingerprints from the pocket watch's case and crystal. It's best to have the watch professionally cleaned every few years when it comes to internal cleaning. An expert can disassemble the watch, clean each component, and then reassemble it, ensuring its longevity.
  • Always Handle with Care. It might go without saying, but always treat your vintage pocket watch with care. A sudden jolt or drop can damage the watch's internal components.

Collecting Vintage Pocket Watches - Final Thoughts

While collecting is about acquiring, it's also about the thrill of the hunt, the joy of discovery, and the stories each piece brings. Every watch has a story; as a collector, you become a part of it. Collecting vintage pocket watches is a delightful journey through time. With its craftsmanship and history, each watch offers a unique connection to the past. By following the above tips, you can ensure that your collection grows in monetary and sentimental value.

Remember, in the world of vintage pocket watches, time isn't just measured in hours and minutes; it's measured in memories, histories, and stories waiting to be discovered. Happy collecting!

Buy or Sell Vintage Pocket Watches at Around the Block

Around the Block has been Toronto’s go-to destination for collectible timepieces on consignment for over 14 years. If you are considering consigning a vintage pocket watch, our certified appraisers can help you assess the items' value and history. If you are a collector of pocket watches, be sure to check out our ever-changing collection of pocket watches online or in our showroom.

← Older Post Newer Post →